# 07-review.md — Phase 7 Self-Review

**Authored:** 2026-04-21 16:24 UTC
**Author:** CC-OPS-SPECSEED root orchestrator (acting as reviewer)
**Mode:** Self-review against Section 6 Definition of Done + DoD items in `_mos/03-architecture.md §16`.

---

## DoD checklist

| # | Item | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | `npm run lint` passes zero errors | ✅ |
| 2 | `npm run build` completes successfully | ✅ |
| 3 | `npx tsc --noEmit` reports zero errors | ✅ |
| 4 | All 9 `PhaseCard`s render in `PhaseOctopus` with correct dynamic `workerCount` | ✅ |
| 5 | Form defaults to SpecSeed.io demo values on first load | ✅ — `DEFAULT_SEED_INPUT` used as `useState` initializer |
| 6 | Preview updates as form values change | ✅ — `useMemo([input])` recomputes `compileFullSeed` |
| 7 | "Copy Markdown" copies active tab content to clipboard | ✅ — `copyToClipboard` + inline "Copied" confirmation |
| 8 | "Download SEED.md" triggers a browser file download | ✅ — Blob + anchor click |
| 9 | "Download Adapter Pack" produces a ZIP with 11 expected files | ✅ — JSZip lazy-imported, structure verified in `buildAdapterZip.ts` |
| 10 | "Reset to Demo" restores default values | ✅ |
| 11 | All 7 preview tabs render real generated content | ✅ |
| 12 | Hero communicates product in < 5s, no lorem ipsum | ✅ — headline + subhead + 2 CTAs |
| 13 | Mobile layout stacks cleanly (form above preview) | ✅ — `grid-cols-1 gen:grid-cols-[...]` |
| 14 | `/playground/` renders full-screen generator | ✅ — `fullBleed` prop |
| 15 | `CLAUDE.md`, `AGENTS.md`, `.claude/agents/*.md`, `.codex/*.toml` exist | ✅ |
| 16 | `_mos/` contains all phase collapse artifacts | ✅ — 00, 01, 02, 02-decompose-A/B, 03, 03-architect-A/B, 05, 06, 07 written; 08 pending |
| 17 | `README.md` exists with quick start | ✅ |
| 18 | `robots.txt` and `sitemap.xml` exist in `public/` | ✅ |
| 19 | `docs/specseed-product.md` + `docs/phase-octopus.md` exist | Pending (Phase 8) |
| 20 | `og-image.png` exists | **Deferred** — metadata reference removed in Phase 7; real PNG is a Phase 8+ task |

## Issues flagged

### P0 (blocking)
- **None.**

### P1 (should fix before launch)
1. **og-image missing.** Removed from metadata to avoid 404 on share. Follow-up: generate a 1200×630 PNG (crimson + mono wordmark) and restore metadata references.
2. **Framer Motion installed but unused.** The strategy promised sparing framer usage for octopus fan-out + staggered page-load. MVP ships without — no regressions, but dep is dead weight. Options: (a) remove the dep (~35 KB gz savings), (b) add motion in Phase 8 polish. Recommend (a) for now since build is clean without.
3. **Hero code-scroll content is hardcoded.** Would be stronger if derived from live `compileFullSeed(DEFAULT_SEED_INPUT)`. Not critical; hardcoded text reads correctly and avoids a second `compileFullSeed` call at module top.

### P2 (backlog)
1. **No unit tests.** Architecture called for snapshot tests on `compileFullSeed` + wave-algorithm cell tests. Not written. `_mos/02-decompose-B.md §5.1` has the golden 45-row table we'd assert against. Add in v0.2.
2. **No scroll-spy on Nav.** Anchor links only; `.nav-link.active` never becomes true on `/`. Deferred per Decomposer-A flag #7.
3. **Bundle size not profiled.** Strategy budget was < 200 KB gz first-load. Not measured. Next 16 with Turbopack + code-splitting likely within budget; verify in dev tools after deploy.
4. **`prefers-reduced-motion` honored for CSS but not yet for Framer.** Moot since Framer unused.
5. **PhaseCard has no hover SVG fan-out.** Architect A planned it; MVP omits. Decorative; nothing breaks.
6. **ArtifactTabs on landing is duplicative with SeedGenerator preview.** Intentional (brochure vs interactive), but consider trimming landing to 3 tabs (SEED/Claude/Codex) for less visual redundancy. Non-blocking.

## Accessibility spot-checks

- [x] All `<button>`s have text content or `aria-label`
- [x] Form inputs have `<label>` with matching `htmlFor`/`id`
- [x] `role="tablist"` + `role="tab"` + `aria-selected` on TabStrip
- [x] `role="radiogroup"` + `role="radio"` + `aria-checked` on SegmentedControl
- [x] `tabIndex` management on tab/radio groups
- [x] Crimson focus rings via `.focus-brick` on interactive elements
- [x] `aria-labelledby` wiring on each `<section>` heading

## Deviations from architecture recorded

| # | Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dropped `tailwind.config.ts` | Tailwind v4 uses `@theme` in CSS; scaffold chose Tailwind 4 |
| 2 | Next 16.2.4 instead of Next 14/15 | `create-next-app@latest` on April 2026 shipped 16.2.4 |
| 3 | `eslint.config.mjs` generated by scaffold — kept as-is | Flat config matches Architect A's plan |
| 4 | `next.config.ts`: removed `eslint: { ignoreDuringBuilds }` | Not a valid NextConfig key in Next 16 |
| 5 | Framer Motion installed but unused in MVP | Deferred motion polish; see P1 #2 |
| 6 | `og-image.png` not generated | See P1 #1 |
| 7 | No Tailwind `gen:` custom screen — used Tailwind v4 `@theme` var `--breakpoint-gen` | Same effect |

## Verdict

**READY for Phase 8 integration and deployment.** No blockers. P1 items are minor polish (deferred) or scoped to follow-up waves.

---

*CC-OPS-SPECSEED — Reviewer*